Plaza Design Projects, from Purpose to Pilot

Lesson 4.1

Name the Purpose

Before drawing, write one sentence that says what your plaza is for. "A sunny lunchtime room for office workers and nearby residents." "A forecourt where library visitors can wait, meet and spill out for events." The sentence will be tested by every decision that follows. If a proposed element does not serve it, cut the element or revise the sentence honestly.

Precedents help calibrate ambition. Piazza del Campo in Siena, paved in brick in the fourteenth century and divided into nine sections, slopes toward the Palazzo Pubblico so that people seated anywhere can see the whole space; it hosts daily life and the twice-yearly Palio horse race. Paley Park in Manhattan, designed by Zion & Breen and opened in 1967, fits a waterfall wall, honey locust trees, movable chairs and a kiosk into a narrow mid-block lot. Superkilen in Copenhagen, completed in 2012 by BIG, Topotek 1 and the artist group Superflex, gathered objects suggested by residents from dozens of countries to express a diverse neighborhood.

Lesson 4.2

Design the Edges First

Most of a plaza's life happens within a few meters of its edges. Gehl's research on ground-floor frontages showed that active, permeable building edges, with doors, windows and places to pause, draw people in and keep them there. For each of your four edges, record what lies behind it, whether people can sit along it, and whether it offers shelter. Then design: a seating step, a café spill-out zone, a planted bench, a shaded colonnade.

Lessons 4.3–4.4

Four Plaza Checks

Run each check against your purpose sentence.

Project for Public Spaces, founded in 1975 by Fred Kent with Whyte's encouragement, popularized the idea that a great place offers many reasons to visit, sometimes called "the power of 10." List at least five things someone could do in your plaza at different hours.

High-contrast photograph of people gathered around a fountain in a stone plaza under strong afternoon light — Water draws people together and softens the sound of the city.

Moody photograph of a temporary street plaza pilot with painted ground, planters and folding chairs — A painted, reversible pilot can test a layout for one season before permanent works.

Lesson 4.5

Pilot Before Pouring

In 2009 New York City closed parts of Broadway around Times Square to traffic as a pilot, using paint, planters and folding chairs. Counts of pedestrians and observations of use supported making the plaza permanent; the redesigned plaza by Snøhetta was completed in 2016. The lesson for a student project is that the riskiest assumption in your plan can often be tested cheaply. Project for Public Spaces calls this "Lighter, Quicker, Cheaper."

Identify the one move you are least certain about, perhaps relocating a bus shelter or closing a slip road, and design a temporary version: materials, duration, who must agree, and what you will count to judge success. Return to the Unit 1 tally method to measure before and after.

Write the Final Rationale

Close the course with a single page. Restate your purpose sentence, then list each major design move with the observation that justifies it, using the sentence form from Unit 1: "Because we observed X, the design does Y." Add the pilot and its success measures. This page is the core of a defensible proposal, the document you would hand to a parks department, a planning committee or a studio jury.

Ask a Design Tutor